|
4th Home
Calendar
State Association News
Current News
Search Our Web Site
Training
Staff
4th District
C O P E
4th District
Political Action Center
NEW!
Organizing
Suggested Reading for Union Leaders
Report
A Violation of Your Rights
Resource Links
Flanagans Links


Click Pic for DSL
56K
Dialup (slow but same message)

...
other menu items
|
WHAT THE
"UNION BUSTERS"
WILL TELL THE
BOSS TO SAY
The "union buster" will
play predictable themes in order to create fear and
confusion about the Union. The basic themes will be repeated
again and again in the frequent letters the "union busters"
will write for the top boss, in the regular
"sermons/lectures" the "union busters" will prepare for your
supervisors and the speeches and videos they will prepare
for the larger, mandatory "captive audience" meetings.
After letters are
delivered and after a one-on-one or captive audience
meeting, ask your colleagues if they have any questions.
Answer all questions to the best of your ability. But, if
you don't know the answer to a question, tell that person
that you will find out and get right back to them.
Here are examples of the
typical themes that are repeated over and over in letters,
captive audience meetings, one-on-ones, 'casual" discussions
with supervisors and, even on videos.
|
WHAT THEY WILL SAY |
WHAT WE KNOW THE TRUTH
IS |
|
We have heard
some talk about unions. We are against having a
union at our Company. Unions bring problems." |
We understand that management doesn't want us to
have a union. The management would prefer to keep
all of the power in their hands. Wouldn't it be good
if the management respected our decision to support
the union and the careful thought and consideration
that went into that decision? Frankly, we have
lots of problems at our Company without a union. We
believe that we can actually do a better job dealing
with the many real problems our Company faces if
we have the voice our union can give us
on all decisions affecting us and the jobs we do.
|
|
"A number of
people have approached me about union salespeople
harassing them. Visiting their houses, calling them
up at all hours. You do not have to talk to these
people. You have a right to say you are not
interested. If you have any problems, let me know
and I'll try to help out." |
Support for the Union is voluntary and an act of
courage and commitment. The Union would be harming
our cause if we did these things.
By the way, what do they call it when they give
us letter after letter disparaging us and
require us to attend one-on-one and group
meetings - on paid time, while our work is piling
up? |
|
"It has not
been easy at our Company recently. We appreciate the
hard work and sacrifices everyone has made. Let's
work out whatever problems we have together, among
ourselves as we always have in the past. After all,
we are a family!" |
We appreciate the appreciation . . . even though
it's a bit curious that only now, when we are trying
to build our union, are they telling us how much
they appreciate us. We do want to work
out problems "together" in the future as we would
love for our Company to be like a "family". When our
Union is voted in, we should work together
to negotiate a first-rate contract, and to tackle
all the problems our Company faces.
Let's build a "family" where we are equals . . .
not one where there is a "father", a few "aunts and
uncles", and the rest of us are "children"! We
look forward to being a "family of partners" once we
have our Union. |
|
"A number of
people have stopped and asked me whether they can
get their union cards back. Yes you can! And here's
how you go about it . . . " |
Of course, no one really has. But, if anyone asked
for their card back, they know that they can have it
anytime . . . and vote "No" on the secret ballot on
Election Day. At this point in the campaign when
Union support is so obviously strong, they are
trying to create the impression that people have
been tricked or bullied into signing something and
are now having "second thoughts".
It's just like those political ads where "average
people" like us are telling the camera that they
have changed their minds because they just don't
trust the candidate. |
|
"The union
salespeople are making lots of promises. They will
say anything to get your support. Remember, it's the
Company that has provided you with the fine wages
and benefits you now enjoy. " |
Again, we are not that gullible. It's getting a
little insulting for them to keep suggesting that we
are so easily tricked and misled. The only thing
that the union organizers promised us was that they
will work with us to achieve the
things that we decide are best for us,
our customers, and the Company.
It's not fair to suggest the we are ungrateful
because we want a say on the Company's priorities.
We think that maybe the Company's resources might be
better spent if we has a say in the
decisions. We also think that we would have better
policies and improved working conditions if we were
part of the decision-making process. We think that
being pro-union is being pro-Company. |
|
"Be careful
about signing a union card! Union organizers may
have told you that signing a cars is like signing a
contract. By signing a union card, you may be
signing away your right to speak for yourselves. By
signing a union card, you may be stuck with the
union - even without an election! Be careful . . .
think about the consequences . .It's a lot like
signing a blank check! |
Give us a little more credit. We are not so easily
misled and tricked! Each one of us knew what we were
doing when we signed union cards. We all gave a lot
of thought to signing a card. We signed because we
wanted the union and the unity and empowerment that
it brings. In fact, the union organizer told us
not to sign unless we were committed to
these things.
With our union, we will finally have the right to
speak for ourselves without fear. |
|
"Union
salespeople are still making lots of promises. They
are promising higher wages, better benefits, job
security . . . there are really no guarantees
with a union! Bargaining is a give and take process.
The Company doesn't have to agree to anything the
union proposes. The union cannot force the Company
to give more than we are willing and able to give.
Everything is on the table and it is possible
that you may lose some of the good things you have
now. Ask the union salespeople to guarantee in
writing what they are going to do for you!" |
Once again, the union organizer hasn't promised or
guaranteed anything. In fact, they told us that this
would be a difficult process with a lot of intense
anti-union campaigning and rhetoric from management.
The only "guarantee" we want is the right to have
a real voice, to have rules and
policies that cannot be changed on a whim and are
applied differently each day in each department. Its
also about having the legal right to
negotiate on all matters affecting
wages, hours, and working conditions!
We know that management will not guarantee
these things to us.
We don't want to "force" the management or the
Board of the Company into doing anything that is bad
for the Company. We want to be full partners in
making decisions that are good for the
Company, its customers, and its employees. Frankly,
we think better decisions will be made if all of us
are part of the decision making process than is the
case now, when only a few managers are making all of
the decisions.
"Everything" may be on the table, if management
chooses to be spiteful, vindictive, and
disrespectful after we win. But, we hope they will
be better than that! WE intend to
bargain in good faith. We hope they will too!
Ask them to give us some examples of IBEW
contracts where employees went backward in their
first contract. We have lots of examples of very
good things workers like us have accomplished with
the IBEW. We are trying to organize our Union to try
to do the same. |
|
"You'll be
hearing lots of rumors . . . lots of pretty
incredible and outrageous statements from the union
salespeople. We will try to provide you with the
FACTS throughout this union campaign. Feel free
to call me anytime with any questions.
|
If they are so interested in getting us the "facts",
why won't they allow open discussions and debate in
the meetings they require us to attend? Why won't
they agree to something like "open forums" every
week where we can come -- voluntarily -- and ask the
"union busters" and representatives of the union any
questions we want? Why won't they sign the
"agreement on Campaign Rules for a Fair Election?" |
|
"This has been a
very hard time for unions. Membership is at its
lowest level in decades. Unions have to fins some
other way to keep up their incomes and to keep
paying the high salaries they pay their officers and
their organizers/salespeople. Organizing our Company
is worth over $25,000 per year to this union! That's
why you are so important to them! |
We know that by law every penny
the union collects in union dues has to be spent on
membership services. Yes, that includes the
salaries, benefits, and expenses of the union staff
people who work for us. Union staff people help us
negotiate contracts, work with us on grievances and
arbitrations, lobby for us in state legislatures and
in Washington, D.C., run workshops and training
programs, help us with safety and health programs
and do a lot of other things that make our jobs more
secure, make working conditions safer and healthier,
and help us improve the quality of service we
provide to the Company's customers. Membership
brings other benefits as well, such as discounts on
various insurance plans, prescription drugs, travel,
and subscriptions.
All of the Union's finances are a matter of
public record.
Why doesn't the Company make all of the same
information available? Why won't they tell us what
they are paying the "union buster" and lawyers they
have hired to defeat our organizing?
|
|
"Have the union
salespeople really told you the whole truth about
what a union might cost you? What about fines?
Assessments? Other charges? What would a strike cost
you? Can you really afford this Union? After all,
you now receive a very competitive wage and benefit
package without being forced to pay dues!" |
YES. . . the union organizers have told us
the whole truth about what the union will cost us.
We know exactly what the basic dues are. We know
what the initiation fees are. We also know that
fines and assessments are very rare, and that we
will have total say over them. We also know that we
will not pay union dues until we have a contract
that we have voted to accept.
We also know that not having a
union can cost us . . . in lower wages, reduced
hours, reduction in benefits, the absence of job
security and seniority rights, a grievance procedure
that is not enforceable and doesn't guarantee our
rights. We believe that union dues are a good
investment for us. |
|
"More and more
staff are complaining to me about union supporters
harassing and badgering them about the union. You do
not have to listen to them! While I cannot stop them
from legitimate campaigning - in non-work areas and
on non-work time - I will do all I can to prevent
harassment. Any employee attempting to distribute
literature or campaigning for the union - or,
against the union - while working will be warned,
and if necessary, disciplined. " |
Hey, wait a minute! It's the Company who is flooding
us with letters, making us listen to our
supervisors' prepared anti-union speeches, and sit
through the videos and lectures of the "captive
audience" meetings on paid time, while our work
piles up! Isn't it time for the Company to let up?
We know where to find our supervisors and
managers if we have any questions. |
|
"The Union is a
'third party'. They are outsiders. We don't need
outsiders or 'third parties' coming in here and
telling us what to do. We don't want outsiders
driving a wedge between us. The outsiders will spoil
the close-knit family relationships that have been
built up." |
WE are the Union, and we are not
"outsiders". WE will make every decision in
our union. WE will elect our own officers and
stewards. WE will decide our bargaining
proposals, negotiate our own contracts, and vote on
the contract. A Union does not "drive a wedge"
between us, if management respects our decision and
legal right to have a union and shares our
commitment to a new era and a better future at our
Company. |
|
"Along with a
union comes the risk of a strike! If the Company is
unwilling or unable to meet the union's demands,
they can call a strike! A strike would be very bad
for our customers . . . And for you! If the union
calls a strike, you could lose a of money! Strikes
have been known to last for months and some places
have even been forced to close down because of
strikes. A strike would set friend against friend,
colleague against colleague and open wounds that
would be hard to heal." |
We know that their is the risk of a strike. The risk
of a strike was considered by each of us before we
decided to support the Union. Just because we have a
union, doesn't mean that overnight we become
uncaring and reckless people.
We know that strikes happen very rarely. We know
that only we will decide whether or
not to strike. We know that Federal Law has a number
of safeguards built into it to help avoid strikes.
We know that even if there is a strike, each
individual has the legal right to go to work.
We think that the risk is small enough and our
control over the decision is complete enough that
there is a risk worth taking considering all of the
good we can accomplish through our union. |
|
"We are really
sorry about all the stress and tension and bad
feelings that this union campaign has created at the
Company. We really wish that it wasn't this way.
Fortunately this will soon all be over! By voting
"No" we can be assured that we can get back to
talking directly to one another again, without a
third party interfering. By voting "No" , we can get
back to being the kind of Company we used to be
before the union arrived. And, we can start working
together to become the kind of Company we all want
to be." |
Isn't it true that the Company and its "union
busters" created all this stress and tension? If
they had just respected our decision and our rights
to vote in a peaceful, democratic atmosphere, this
wouldn't have been such a difficult time at the
Company. We suppose this is what they paid the
"union buster" to do. Boy, all of that money could
have been much better spent.
By voting "No", we are really saying that it's
O.K. for management to continue making all of the
decisions for us. That's not really the best thing
for us at the Company. We want the Company to be
better than it was before, and we believe
that through our union it can be. |
|
"If the union
wins, you may lose many of your individual rights.
Will you still have the right to speak for yourself
when the union makes the rules? Did you know that
the Union can punish you if they do not like what
you say or do? The union constitution actually says
that the union can discipline members! Have union
organizers shown you the union constitution? What
are they trying to hide? |
What "rights" do we have now? How often have rules
and policies been changed on a whim? How often are
rules and policies applied differently to different
people and differently by different supervisors? And
what good is a "grievance procedure" where we do not
have the right to representation, to
see the evidence against us and to have the
Company's Management as the last appeal?
With the IBEW, rules and policies cannot be
changed at the drop of a hat, and they have to be
enforced fairly, consistently, and uniformly. Every
IBEW contract has a clearly spelled out grievance
procedure with the right to representation and the
right to an outside third party appeal -
arbitration. That will be quite an improvement over
what we have now.
And yes, we have seen the union constitution. The
IBEW is built on the principles of local control and
autonomy and respect for the rights of the
individual. |
|
Related Information:
|